| Ref No | GB-110/JES/COR/12/23 |
| Title | Samuel Goodenough to Sir James Edward Smith |
| Description | Reports from evening part of Linnean Society anniversary meeting: fifty-four members present, including: [Aylmer Bourke] Lambert, Lord [Edward Smith-]Stanley, [William George] Maton, Sir Thomas Cullum, [Thomas Andrew] Knight, Mr Greenough, two Forsters, Mr Simmonds, [James] Dickson, [Thomas] Hoy [(c 1750-1822)], Holmes, Mr Burchall, [Thomas] Rackett, and [William] Kirby. [Thomas] Marsham apologised by letter for not repaying the £100 as intended and proposed to repay the remainder in installments. Goodenough advised [Alexander] Macleay [also spelt McLeay or M'Leay] not to publicise this so as to avoid further disappointment. Marsham's name was not mentioned during the toasts at the dinner, and by accident Sir Joseph Banks and the honorary members were also overlooked.
President of the Horticultural Society [Thomas Andrew Knight] offended by [Patrick] Keith's treatment of him in "Physiology of Plants" ["A system of physiological botany"]. Shocked to see how old Kirby looks and how "amazingly distended" Hoy's chest is. Believes it would be better to reduce rather than increase number of FMLS, cites example of Royal Society who are reducing their foreign members to thirty; thinks forty is sufficiently large for Linnean Society, and proposes keeping ten spaces free for emergencies. In postscript states that whenever Marsham's name was mentioned there was silence. |
| Date | 24 May [1816] |
| Level | Item |
| Extent | 4 pp |
| Language | English |
| Related Material | For further on dispute between Knight and Keith, see letter from Knight to Smith of 12 June 1816, JES/COR/16/104, letter from Knight to Smith of 16 July 1817, JES/ADD/52, letter from Knight to Smith of 21 March 1818, JES/ADD/53, and letter from Smith to Macleay of 4 April 1818, JES/AM/140.
Keith, P, (1816). "A system of physiological botany ..." London: Baldwin. |
| Notes | Smith replied 27 [May 1816] |
| PrevRefNo | 12.39 |
| Creator Name | Goodenough, Samuel (1743-1827) |
| Access_Status | Open |
| Code | PersonName | Dates |
| GB/110/1/35 | Goodenough; Samuel (1743-1827); Bishop of Carlisle | 1743-1827 |
| GB/110/1/25 | Lambert; Aylmer Bourke (1761-1842); botanist | 1761-1842 |
| GB/110/1/294 | Stanley; Edward Smith- (1775-1851); 13th Earl of Derby; politician and naturalist | 1775-1851 |
| GB/110/1/203 | Maton; William George (1774-1835); physician | 1774-1835 |
| GB/110/1/195 | Cullum; Sir; Thomas Gery (1741-1831); 7th baronet; surgeon and herald | 1741-1831 |
| GB/110/1/34 | Knight; Thomas Andrew (1759-1838); horticulturist and plant physiologist | 1759-1838 |
| GB/110/1/60 | Dickson; James (1738-1822); botanist | 1738-1822 |
| GB/110/1/129 | Kirby; William (1759-1850); entomologist and naturalist | 1759-1850 |
| GB/110/1/17 | Marsham; Thomas (? 1747-1819); entomolgist | ? 1747-1819 |
| GB/110/1/95 | Macleay; Alexander (1767-1848); entomologist and civil servant in Australia | 1767-1848 |
| GB/110/1/9 | Banks; Sir; Joseph (1743-1820); Baronet; Naturalist and patron of science | 1743-1820 |
| GB/110/1/466 | Rackett; Thomas (1755-1840); Church of England clergyman and antiquary | 1755-1840 |